Telephone Transmitter: Fixed-voltage Resistance Comparison

← Back to Engineering Library

A granular-carbon telephone transmitter uses a diaphragm to act on a carbon element whose resistance can vary in the circuit. This calculator compares two entered resistance states under an explicit fixed-voltage assumption; it is not an acoustic or microphone-performance model.

Telephone Transmitter Interactive Calculator

Enter state-A resistance, state-B resistance and state-A current. The model holds the implied voltage V = I_A R_A fixed while evaluating state B.

0°

State-A current
--
Fixed-voltage state-B current
--
Signed current difference
--
Signed resistance change
--

Equation Used

V = I_A R_A; I_B = V/R_B = I_A R_A/R_B; delta I = I_B - I_A; signed R change = 100(R_A-R_B)/R_A.
Positive current difference means state B draws more current than state A. Positive signed resistance change means R_B is lower. The entered states are not derived from sound pressure or diaphragm motion.
  • The voltage implied by state A remains fixed while state B is evaluated.
  • Both entered resistances are positive lumped circuit values.
  • The calculation is steady-state Ohm's-law arithmetic only.
  • Sound pressure, diaphragm mechanics, carbon contact physics, circuit source impedance, transformer behavior, frequency response, distortion, heating and ratings are omitted.
Same mechanism and inputs as the interactive calculator.

Granular-carbon Transmitter Principle

Edison's 1889 patent describes a diaphragm acting on a body of carbon granules included in an electrical circuit so that diaphragm action varies the circuit resistance. That historical construction supports the qualitative mechanism shown here.

The illustration is conceptual. It does not reproduce a particular patent drawing or derive resistance from sound pressure, granule packing, diaphragm travel or frequency.

What This Explanatory Calculator Does

The calculator applies Ohm's law to two user-entered resistance states. It first infers a fixed voltage from state A, then calculates the current that the same voltage would produce in state B.

It does not predict microphone sensitivity, voice current, loudness, frequency response, distortion, noise, heating, service life or compatibility with a telephone circuit.

Fixed-voltage State Comparison

V = IARA;   IB = V/RB = IARA/RB;   ΔI = IB−IA

The signed relative resistance change is 100(RA−RB)/RA. A positive value means state B has lower resistance; a negative value means it has higher resistance.

Worked Electrical-state Comparison

For RA = 50 ohm, RB = 20 ohm and IA = 30 mA, the implied fixed voltage is 1.5 V. State-B current is 75 mA, the signed current difference is +45 mA and the signed resistance change is +60%.

Those results follow from the entered values and fixed-voltage assumption; they do not establish that a real sound input will create either resistance state.

Model Boundary

  • Calculated: two steady-state currents, their signed difference and signed relative resistance change under a fixed implied voltage.
  • Historical arrangement: a diaphragm can act on carbon granules in a circuit to vary resistance.
  • Not calculated: resistance-versus-pressure behavior, granule contact physics, diaphragm mechanics, source impedance, transformer action, waveform, frequency response, sensitivity, sound pressure, distortion, noise, power dissipation, heating, ratings, materials, wear, life or safety.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is state B a predicted loud-voice peak?

No. It is a user-entered resistance state.

Why can state-B current be lower?

If RB exceeds RA, the same voltage produces less current, so the signed difference is negative.

Is the voltage an independent input?

No. It is implied by state-A current and resistance: V = IARA.

Does this predict sound output?

No. No acoustic or mechanical transfer function is present.

Does it include the rest of a telephone circuit?

No. Source impedance, coils, transformers, wiring and receiver loading are omitted.

Can it set a safe operating current?

No. Device ratings and heating are not modeled.

References

Building or designing a mechanism like this?

Explore the precision-engineered motion control hardware used by mechanical engineers, makers, and product designers.

← Back to Mechanisms Index
Share This Article
Tags: